Why You Owe Taxes on Capital Gains: Even If You Didn’t Sell or Withdraw

If you received your 1099 tax form this year and were surprised to see capital gains listed even though you didn't sell any investments or withdraw funds, you're not alone. This is a common and often frustrating experience for many investors.

So, what's going on? Let's break down why this happens, how mutual fund investing works, and how to think about these taxes as part of a smart long-term financial strategy.

Why Am I Paying Taxes If I Didn't Sell Anything?

Short answer: You're likely paying taxes on capital gains distributions from mutual funds, which are taxable even if you didn't make any trades or withdrawals.

Mutual funds are considered pass-through investment vehicles. That means when fund managers sell assets inside the fund, whether to rebalance, meet redemptions, or capture gains, those profits are distributed to you, the investor, in the form of capital gains.

You'll see these listed on Form 1099-DIV or 1099-B, and they are considered taxable income for the year, even if those distributions were automatically reinvested and never hit your bank account.

What Are Capital Gains Distributions?

Capital gains distributions result from sales that occur within the mutual fund, not in your personal account. They are categorized as either:

• Short-term capital gains: Investments held less than one year
• Long-term capital gains: Investments held for more than one year

Regardless of whether you reinvest the distributions or receive them as cash, they are taxable in the year they are received.

Why Do These Distributions Increase in Strong Market Years?

In years like 2024, when market performance has been broadly positive, mutual fund managers have more opportunities to realize gains. This is especially true for:

• Actively managed funds with high turnover
• Funds with structural index changes
• Funds responding to investor redemptions

Even mutual funds held for many years can carry embedded gains that are being realized and distributed as the fund repositions.

What If I Only Own Individual Stocks?

If you own individual stocks and haven't sold anything, you won't have capital gains. However, if you work with a portfolio manager who actively trades on your behalf, any realized gains will still show up on your year-end tax documents.

Key difference: Portfolios built with individual securities typically allow for more tax control compared to mutual funds.

There's a Silver Lining: Your Cost Basis Increases

Here's the upside: When capital gains distributions are reinvested, they increase your cost basis. That means when you eventually sell the investment, the gain on which you'll owe tax is smaller.

In essence, you're paying a portion of the tax now, which can help spread out the tax impact over time and reduce future liabilities.

Tax-Efficient Investing: What We're Doing to Help Minimize These Taxes

At our firm, we prioritize tax-efficient investing as the core tenet of how we manage your wealth. Our approach includes:

• Using tax-loss harvesting to offset gains when appropriate
• Monitoring mutual fund turnover and avoiding tax-inefficient holdings
• Building portfolios with a blend of individual securities and tax-efficient funds
• Customizing strategies based on your broader financial plan and tax situation

This kind of tax management is particularly important if you have a taxable brokerage account, where proactive decisions can significantly reduce your lifetime tax burden.

Bottom Line

Receiving a tax bill for investments you didn't sell can feel frustrating, but it's a standard part of mutual fund investing. In most cases, it's actually a sign that your investments are growing.

If you'd like help reviewing your Form 1099s or want to discuss strategy for minimizing future taxes, we're here to help.

FAQ

Why am I being taxed on investments I didn't sell?

Mutual funds pass on profits from internal trading to investors as capital gains distributions. These are taxable, even if you didn't sell anything yourself.

Are capital gains distributions always taxable?

Yes. Capital gains are considered taxable income in the year they are distributed, regardless of whether they are reinvested or taken in cash.

How can I reduce taxes from capital gains distributions?

Strategies include tax-loss harvesting, favoring tax-efficient funds, and using individual stocks for greater control over taxable events.

Any discussion of taxes is for general information purposes only, does not purport to be complete or cover every situation, and should not be construed as legal, tax, or accounting advice. Clients should confer with their qualified legal, tax, and accounting advisors as appropriate.

CRN202803-8441241